![]()
In episode 1 our protagonist, Kazuya Maeda, made the questionable choice of joining the photography club, which is a den of perverts for the most part. Will he turn out to be a creep, or was it a big mistake?
This series garnered a lot of discussion on various message boards because of the creepiness/perverseness of the Photography Club members and the perception that Kazuya, as the main character, was also a creep like them, since he joined their club. Many of the arguments displayed the general lack of understanding of the rights of photographers, which, as a professional photographer, I always find disheartening. To put it bluntly, nothing that the main character did in the first week was remotely close to a violation of either the laws that photographers work under or any ethical standards. Taking pictures of people in public places is perfectly legal. What is not legal is using those pictures without permission. Interestingly, the Photography Club, den of perverts and creeps that it is, explicitly stated that they don't use photos unless they have permission from the subject. This was brushed off as meaningless by so many posters on so many sites that it is maddening! In any case, it was rather interesting that a show with such a reserved level of fan service, given the basic theme of the show, caused so much discussion.
Enough ranting, since this week's episode answers several of the questions about the moral character of our protagonist, while opening up new ones at the end. He states several times that he would never take pictures of girls that are degrading or rude, as many of the people ask him about it, given his club choice. In addition to saying that he wouldn't do such things, he seems legitimately uncomfortable with the fact that the other members of the Photography Club do take pictures like that.
Review:
The art continues to be a bit of a disappointment, with several times when the faces of the girls were poorly rendered, like the nose entirely disappearing except when in profile, etc… These are common issues with anime, but it is still disappointing. Worse than that is the animation. There are far too many places where the animators use pans over still images, even for things like people playing tennis and other action-oriented activities. Really, the only place where the animation and art step up to an acceptable level are when Kazuya is taking pictures. Then the animators make good use of the camera viewfinder, sometimes to somewhat humorous effect, like the shot to the left, with the focus point activating in a very suggestive manner.
On the topic of fan service, I have been surprised at how little of it there has been and how reserved as well. Take this set of pictures for example:
![]()
This was just one of many scenes in the episode where there could have been an easy panty-shot, but they chose to avoid them entirely. Yes, the camera lingers on the hips, legs, backsides, cleavage, etc… especially when the protagonist is framing a shot, but they don't stoop to gratuitous up-skirt or down-blouse shots. Instead, by showing the process of framing a photo, and all of the options Kazuya has in the process, then showing the final shot he takes being not only appropriate in terms of prurient content, but also in terms of the general standards of good photography (rule of thirds, selective focus, etc…). When you add to that the fact that, in one scene, he actually solicits advice on exposure settings from one of the fellow photo enthusiasts at his school, it really paints a good picture of a young photographer learning the ropes.
The music is still unremarkable, with the best use of sound having to do with the shutter effects. Story wise, the show picks it up a notch this week. While the big question at the end of episode 1 (Why was Tomoe crying?) was answered in a round-about way and with a very ho-hum answer to boot, the relationship dynamics of the story took a step forward, both between the protagonist and the female lead and the protagonist and the members of his new club. (Yes, it is a harem, but to be honest, it is very clear from the beginning that Haruka Nimi is the leading lady.)
Last week, Haruka's eyes seemed to cling to Kazuya's face, with a rather sad look of longing, as she innocently asked about why she never got to see him over break. This foreshadowing was followed up this week by an almost brazen, just shy of a confession, scene. Kazuya's level of cluelessness seems to be rather high at this point, which could be an issue if it continues.
The other area where the story moved forward is with the student body president, Aki Muroto. (In last week's entry, I mentioned her as being on the swimming team. That may still be the case, as she is featured in a swimsuit in the OP and in the previews for next week, but it appears that being the student council president is the more important aspect.) She continues to berate Kazuya for minor violations of the rules and for a general lack of familiarity with said school rules. However, near the end of the episode, Kazuya catches her in a compromising situation, which results in what he refers to as “Blackmail material.” This opens up some questions about Kazuya's moral character again, however, given the amount that Aki had been dogging him about the small stuff, I find it perfectly understandable that he might think about the fact that he has figured out a weak spot in little miss perfects facade as an opportunity. It is only human nature to recognize that having leverage to use against someone in a position of power is desirable, even if it would be wrong and mean to use that information against them.
All in all, I am enjoying this show more than I really feel I should based on the technical merits of the show. Perhaps it is the fact that I have read some of the manga, but the show just sort of rises above the lack of execution and polish. I suppose it could be that I find the main characters quite likable?
Episode Highlights:
![]()
We start out with Tomoe Misumi arriving at class and seeming to take extra effort to pass near Kazuya. Could it symbolize something? Maybe something to do with the big secret she shared in episode 1? Hard to tell…
The episode quickly delves into the fan service bin. But wait! It's guys changing into their gym clothes!
![]()
Nonoka sure doesn't look like she's trying to cover her eyes effectively there… hmmm. Anyway, she is coming to deliver some more character assassination … er … I mean development, for our protagonist. She wants to borrow one of his books. She would rather borrow Haruka's, of course, since her notes are so awesome, but his is the next best thing, since it is like having a brand new book with no notes what-so-ever. Nothing to distract you or lead you astray! Yes, they are painting a picture of Kazuya as a fairly poor student who doesn't really try hard. That may be Nonoka's main purpose in the show…
Thanks to Nonoka's delaying him, Kazuya is now running late for gym class, so he has another stairwell collision with the ever bossy student body president, Aki. She informs him that he is supposed walk, not run in the halls, and also that he is to stay to the right side of the hall in order to avoid events like what just happened. He wasn't aware of that, so she
shoves the student handbook in his face and suggests he read his copy. She seems a bit strict…
Next, he see's Haruka looking pretty worn out, hauling softball gear. He asks what's up and she says she is getting them for their gym class. Haruka asks him about having joined the Photography Club, since he has never
been in a club before. (Kanon told her, of course) He tells her that the club president kind of forced him into it and wouldn't take no for an answer, which is kind of how I felt about the whole thing at the time. When she asks what they do in the club, he makes up something about recording the days of youth of the students, which Haruka seems to buy. ![]()
Incidentally, about that time Kazuya notices the perverts from the Photography Club lurking with their cameras to get a picture of Nimi in her bloomers. He offers to give her a hand and she says she's fine. (He is, after all, obviously late for his own gym class already.) But when she bends over to pick up the softball equipment, something shines in her eyes, blinding her. Upset at the situation, he blocks the shots of the other club members and helps her carry the softball gear outside, even forgetting to take off his indoor shoes.
To setup the next scene, his stomach growls embarrassingly while he is talking with Haruka, since he skipped breakfast because he was running late today. After getting clocked by a soccer ball in gym class, probably because he wasn't moving fast enough, he runs into his sister, who seems concerned that he has been hurt. After a stomach growl of truly epic
proportions, he asks if she has anything to eat? She has a vitamin jelly pouch in her skirt pocket, which he gratefully accepts and starts to chug. However, the warmth of it puts to mind where it was, which seems to creep him out a bit. After all, it was snuggled right up to his little sister's upper thigh. (So nice that it doesn't excite him!)
However, this provides Madam President with another opportunity to shove the rule book in his face, since he isn't supposed to eat or drink in the hallway! The fact that she startled him and made him nearly choke doesn't seem to faze her…
Next, he is wandering looking for “shutter chances” and once again comes across his sister's friend Mai doing gymnastics, this time with the whole team. As he lines up a shot, Mai comes over to stop him.
Kanon has told her about his joining the club as well, and she informs him that he is not allowed to take pictures during club practices. The coach has banned the Photography Club due to their trying to take pictures from embarrassing angles. He says he would never do that, which Mai quickly believes. Kazuya is upset because he is already running into limitations as a photographer, so soon after taking up the hobby. She tells him that she will talk with the captain about getting an exemption for him, since he is
not a creep. Not sure how that will work, since it is only his word on that… (Is it me, or is she more developed that lat week? I don't recall her having obvious breasts… but I guess she was wearing a loos fitting t-shirt…)
Speaking of creeps, one of the ever-present Photography Club members, Mr. Low Angle in this case, is there to give Kazuya props for getting cozy with Mai in order to get himself excluded from the club ban. (Not that Kazuya perceives this as what he was doing.) He informs him that the first year “Mai-Kano” duo is crazy popular. Kazuya berates him for doing stuff to get banned in the first place, then asks who this “Mai-Kano” duo is? He gets the Mai part, but who is Kano? None other than
Kanon Maeda! This causes Kazuya to have a bit of a fit prior to informing the idiot that Kanon is his little sister! Kazuya evidently doesn't perceive creepy perverts being into his little sister to be a good thing.
Mr. Low Angle thinks for a moment, then says he needs to start calling Kazuya “Brother” now! Evidently Mr. Low Angle has a bit of a crush? In any event, it promises to be a running gag going forward, which may or may not be funny.
Continuing with the rounds of flag setting for the various heroines, Kazuya happens upon Hikari Sanehara, the Kuudere Photo Club girl, taking pictures against the light of the setting sun. He takes this opportunity to ask her about techniques to compensate for the lighting, since he gets “blocked up shadows”. Her initial response is a cold Who cares as long as it creates a mood. However, she then suggests that he could use the exposure compensation dial. A little bit of the dere side there? Maybe… In any case, he gets a text from his club president calling all of them to the club room after school tomorrow, which he seems to dread. Why did he join this club again?
Next, we come to the meat of the episode – a photo shoot with Haruka! Kazuya is musing over the fact that he was so worried about the meeting that he couldn't sleep. (Again, why are you in this club?) Haruka is returning from the swimming pool, which was the gym class activity for the day. She evidently forgot her hairband or something, and had to go back to get it, leaving her all by herself, in her swimsuit. He starts to beat a hasty retreat, but she stops him and offers to model for him.
He is a bit shocked at the offer. He clarifies that she means in her swimsuit, and she confirms it. She says it will be embarrassing, but she'll do her best because she wants to do what she can to help him with his hobby. When he asks why she would do something like this for him, she responds that she want to spend more time with him, “just like I used to!” She asks if he he doesn't want to, he says that isn't the problem. She responds rather forcefully, saying “Then take it! Take my picture!”. She then gets a bit more shy, looking away, and saying, “If you don't mind, I want you to take my picture.” Then she swings back to a more aggressive stance, saying, “I want you to look at me!” Kazuya looks a bit like a deer in headlights after this… If I may editorialize: Dude! That was practically a love confession you big dope! The most beautiful girl in the school is willing to pose for you in her swimsuit, despite being embarrassed about it, because she wants you to look at her! Climb aboard the clue bus on this one and realize that she is in love with you! Why? Who the heck knows, but don't be an idiot! (Of course, he will eventually be an idiot! That is a given.)
So they do their first photo shoot together, a private, secret, swimsuit photo session. Lucky guy!
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Later, in class, Kazuya does a nifty bit of daydreaming and remembers his discussion with Tomoe that has been danced around the whole episode. What she revealed to him wasn't earth shaking or anything, nor that interesting. (No yuri love tringle this time around it seems…) However, it was sufficient, when it happened to interupt Kazuya's ability to pay
attention in class, to warrant a whack on the head from the hot teacher.
Moving along, we get to the Photography Club's meeting, where Kazuya has yet to learn the club motto and seems totally uncomfortable. The purpose of the meeting is to reveal the winner of this year's “Miss
Photogenic” contest. It is an annual poll by the club members to determine which of the schools photographs the best. The club then puts up a gallery of photos of the girl at the school cultural festival. Kazuya feels sorry for the girl already.![]()
This year's winner is obvious: Haruka Nimi. Kazuya wonders out loud if this is the real reason the club recruited him. The response of Stealth Girl suggests he hit it on the nose! Kazuya is not at all pleased!
The next morning, the hot teacher sends Kazuya to take out the trash, since it had been his turn the night before and he flaked on it. While out there, he decides to take the long way back to class and take a few pictures. ![]()
At the same time, a girl appears to be trying to sneak onto the campus the back way. Kazuya sees this and immediately identifies this as a “Shutter Chance”.
It turns out to be none other than the ultra strict, rule quoting, student body president – Aki Muroto! She gets a bit upset that Kazuya is taking pictures of her in this compromising situation, then in classic rom-com style falls on Kazuya, with her skirt heading directly toward his face at one point.![]()
Aki accuses Kazuya of taking pictures of her panties, he tells her he would never do that! In the end, she tries to use her usual haughty tone with him but he isn't having any of that! He figured out that she was trying to avoid a tardy by coming into the school the back way,
while he has a legitimate reason to be behind the school. She ends up asking him, very sweetly, if he would mind not telling anyone, as it would cause her to lose the respect of the students. He has a bit of a delusion of grandeur as he realizes that the normaly bossy Aki Muroto-sempai is acting all sweet and subdued. He agrees to not tell anyone. She then asks him to delete the pictures he took, which he refuses to do, because it
would be a shame to let good pictures go to waste. As he heads back to class she tells him not to show them to anyone. He says he won't. She pouts, and Kazuya considers the fact that he now has some blackmail material to use against the student body president!
A quick note here, as I'm sure there are tons of posts around the web about how absolutely wrong Kazuya was to not delete those pictures. He was perfectly within his rights to keep them! However, it would be illegal for him to use them for anything other than personal use, since she refused permission. You may think that she has the right to make him delete the pictures, but that is not the case.
![]()
![]()
Previews for next week:
![]()